Home   >   Comment   >   Features   >   201203

Good Friday Is Coming! Why Did Judas Betray Jesus?   
  << Prev  |  Next >>
Comments ( 0 )     Email    Print
Related Stories
In two weeks’ time, the first and second important days on the Christian calendar will rear their heads to be celebrated worldwide-Good Friday and Easter Sunday.

Already, radio, TV and newspapers adverts and announcements are all over, injecting the atmosphere with importance and uniqueness of the two aforesaid holy days– whose impact gives me the urgency to discuss some aspects of them this week and the next. I therefore apologise to my readers for my failure to continue last week’s argument on Libation, which can be held immediately after the Easter.

It is common within the world’s Christendom that the whole crucifixion saga that got climaxed in the death of Christ on Good Friday was triggered off by a singular act of betrayal of one person –Judas Iscariot, an apostle of Christ. A quick recap of the essentials of the events will reveal the facts:

Midnight. The branches of the bushy brambles and the blooming olive trees that stood in the dark Gethsemane garden sadly bowed in still silence. Occasionally, they nodded disapprovingly to the pitiable prayer of the agonising Jesus. Suddenly, some trudging footsteps of soldiers, led by Judas himself, came on over. A kiss on Jesus’ cheeks by Judas. A stampede in the darkness. Jesus was arrested. And as he was being whisked away, the disciples ran helter-skelter through the bushes. Now followed some rapid cascading pietas- those mournful scenarios depicting severe slaps in Jesus’s ear, and bitter beatings and foul floggings that opened wounds and oozed blood droplets from the nailed palms and feet, all to drench Christ’s sweating dying body on the Cross! This sad episode is known to have been caused by Judas’s betrayal, an act which has earned him the contemptuous tag- the traitor.

But some pundits do not agree to that condemnatory accolade- “traitor,” which to them, is wrongly pinned on Judas. Their point is that since without Judas, it would not have been possible to have had Jesus arrested to save mankind from God’s wrath over sins, he (Judas) did no wrong in betraying Jesus. And therefore he does not merit the “traitor” insignia; or any condemnation.

To them, Judas is, at best, God’s sub-instrument of salvation; at worst, a medium through which part of the Christological prophecies (ie. prophecies about Christ) was fulfilled. “By his betrayal act” remarked a scholar recently, “Judas was proving to the world that the scriptures are true, and Christ’s prophecies that someone would betray him, were true”. In a religious symposium held some time ago in Accra, a pro-Judas Bible scholar argued: “people mistakenly condemn Judas for betraying Jesus. But if the betrayal had to be carried on by someone else who never knew the movements and whereabouts of Jesus effectively, could that have been implemented to cause the arrest of Jesus which led to our salvation?”

True, Jesus had been a slippery figure who had, on several occasions, mysteriously disappeared from the hands of the scribes and Pharisees (his sworn enemies) whenever there was an attempt to arrest him. Indeed, to arrest him in an ordinary manner was always illusory, impossible. For one thing, it was all the while difficult for the outsider to distinguish Jesus from the rest of his disciples, since all of them wore similar robes and round beard, and therefore looked alike. For another, it was hard for a stranger to locate precisely the particular secluded spot in the vast Gethsemane woodland where Jesus often retired with his disciples to pray in the night (Luke 22:39). He could only be “caught” there!

In this connection, there was, it was held, the need for an insider to be used to point to the person of Jesus, or where he is, for an effective arrest. It was here that Judas, an insider, came in handy. It is on this view the argument is built to the effect that it was not the intention of Judas to betray Jesus so to be killed. As a believer in the kingdom-is-near theory preached by Jesus (Matthew 3:20), Judas (as De Quincey argues) wanted to simply create a “compromising situation” in which Jesus would bestir himself and manifest his miraculous powers to seize political power in Israel or to secure the earthly kingdom before his(Jesus’) impending departure into heaven.

Two motives are said to be hidden behind Judas’s pressure on Jesus for a coup d’état in Israel. First, his desire to bring into reality the ‘Hossana… blessed is (Jesus) the King of Israel’ idea (John12:13) loudly proclaimed on Palm Sunday. Jesus should by all means be a practical king in Israel. Second, as argued elsewhere, Judas was to create opportunity for himself so to assume his much-desired political office of Minister of Finance of Christ’s expected earthly kingdom of Israel. After all, he had experientially held the position of treasurer of the apostles’ money for the three years (John 12:6), why couldn’t he be the Minister of Finance? A reference point citied to back the argument that Judas meant no harm to Jesus is: Judas’s return of the ‘betrayal money’ (the 30 pieces of silver) to the high priests, when he found that his political kingdom manouevres had backfired into those that were leading to the unfortunate crucifixion of Jesus.

“I have sinned, I have betrayed innocent blood” are the repentant remarks of Judas said to portray his good intentions. But all these arguments are denounced by lots of people who consider the betrayal act as an error of the greatest magnitude: a serious mortal sin committed by Judas. “The argument that without Judas, Christ could not have been arrested to be crucified for our salvation is an intellectual hoax, a big lie” remarked a University don at Legon in our recent discussions on the subject. It was argued there and then that since the Crucifixion for mankind’s salvation was a divinely ordained plan, a freak opportunity could have occurred for the arrest of Jesus even in the streets, in so far as the time for his prophesied death on the Cross had come. The conclusion was that Judas became a causative factor in the arrest and crucifixion of Christ because he was a big bundle of various vices whose intensity was heightened by the fact that:

One, he wrongly felt himself to be side-lined, enstranged or discriminated against by the almost all-Galilean apostles of Christ. His surname Iscariot means: “a man of Kerioth,” a little town in Judea, a different ethnic area. Judas was the only Judean amongst the lot, and he possibly envied the natural cultural links between the Galilean apostles.

Two, he had, as Rev. Professor James Stewart says, “a streak of covetousness in his nature . . . which made him indulge in petty pilfering,” a secret which he feared might be exposed one day to his disgrace.

And three, his dashed hopes for the worldly kingdom in which he would be a high-profile personality – a kind of deflated paranoia – so stung him as to fill him with revenge plans against his master Jesus. From all these, it can be correctly inferred that what exactly actuated the betrayal deed of Judas was outright viciousness, a hidden desire to eliminate Jesus and nothing else. By this logic, the verdict of many men has been, – Judas did err in betraying Jesus. And this error was acknowledged by Judas himself, on the basis of which he hanged himself – a fact which places him squarely in hell, and a lesson to those who indulge in greed, envy, or (nkƆnkƆnsa) betrayal gimmicks in the society.

The contempt against Judas is currently expressed in Bishop Bob Okala-like satirical song: “nea Judas yƐiyi, ƐyƐanaa. . . ?” (literally, what Judas did, was it good . . . ?) Your answer might be as good as mine!
Source: Apostle Kwamena Ahinful/D-Guide

Comments ( 0 ): Post Your Comments >>

Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are those of the writers and do not reflect those of Peacefmonline.com. Peacefmonline.com accepts no responsibility legal or otherwise for their accuracy of content. Please report any inappropriate content to us, and we will evaluate it as a matter of priority.
Featured Video